Scattered red, white, and blue 'I VOTED' round stickers on a white surface
Scattered "I voted" stickers on a white table (Unsplash/ Element5)
The Facts About Voter ID and Limits to Absentee Voting in the 2026 Midterm Elections

If Voters Want to Vote, Not Much Will Stop Them


 

Debates during the 2026 midterm election have focused as much on party and policies as they have on the way we vote. At issue are voter ID laws, which require people to show identification before voting, and potential limits to absentee ballots and mail-in voting.  

Supporters argue that these measures are needed to reduce fraud in U.S. elections. This is despite a consensus among political scientists and other experts that there is no large-scale fraud in U.S. elections.  

Critics argue that these measures increase the cost of voting, which reduces turnout, with some going so far as to label them Jim Crow 2.0. Systematic research in political science has found that this is not the case. 

“As best we understand it, the costs that have been put on people in recent years with voter ID or limiting absentee ballots don’t really lower turnout that much,” said Ben Highton, professor and chair of Political Science in the College of Letters and Science at UC Davis. 

How voter ID laws affect voter turnout 

Currently, 36 states require voters to show identification at the polls. In a 2017 review paper, Highton surveyed studies of voter ID laws to establish a consensus on their impacts on voter turnout. The studies overwhelmingly found that requiring voters to show identification to vote made little difference on how many people voted.  

“All of the evidence pointed to the conclusion that voter identification laws, if anything, had at best very modest effects on turnout,” said Highton. “Their disparate effects were also almost impossible to discern in the data.” 

Voters vote despite long lines at the polls 

Reducing or eliminating absentee or mail-in voting creates an additional barrier to voting in the name of reducing alleged voter fraud. However, a 2020 UCLA study led by UC Davis political scientist Tye Rush found voter fraud to be virtually nonexistent among vote-by-mail ballots. 

Challenges to mail-in voting are among several potential barriers to voting. Another is a reduction in polling sites, like in Tarrant County, Texas, where county officials recently removed 92 polling locations, including one at the University of Texas at Arlington.  

Fewer polling sites can lead to longer lines to vote. The non-partisan Brennan Center for Justice estimates that during the 2018 midterm election, 3 million voters waited 30 minutes or more.  

In a 2006 paper, Highton analyzed how much the availability of voting machines played a role in John Kerry losing Ohio to George W. Bush in the 2004 presidential election. He found that fewer machines led to somewhat lower turnout, but the effect was not strong enough to have changed the election results.  

“If you make it more difficult to vote, turnout does go down, but these effects are quite modest,” said Highton. “Compared to many of the concerns people often express about voting costs, the effects do not appear to justify the worries.” 

How political motivation drives voter turnout

Instead, Highton said that the biggest factor that determines whether people vote is their motivation and political interest. People who follow politics, who are engaged and who care about the outcomes tend to vote regardless of the sort of costs imposed on them by today's voter registration and voting laws.  

He also said that policies like universal voter registration and laws that make absentee voting easy and widespread that further reduce the effort needed to vote would likely not make much difference at all. 

“Laws that affect the cost of voting now compared to the past when there were poll taxes, literacy tests, intimidation, and violence, have quite modest effects,” said Highton. “What really determines who votes and who doesn't is the simple fact of who's interested and engaged in politics and who is not.” 


YOU MAY ALSO LIKE THESE STORIES


Stories Archive

Primary Category

Tags